On this week’s Film Club, A.V. Club critics A.A. Dowd and Ignatiy Vishnevetsky sit down to discuss M. Night Shyamalan’s shameless low-budget B-film Split and take live questions. The twist? They both think it’s the best thing the one-time Hollywood golden boy has done since his heyday in the 2000s, and even if they don’t see eye to eye on The Happening and The Village, they think you should see Split.

Watch the full episode of Film Club below.