On this week’s Film Club, A.V. Club film critics A.A. Dowd and Ignatiy Vishnevetsky talk about their shared fondness for James Mangold’s Logan, a grisly (and very R-rated) superhero flick that is also the most measured and grown-up movie that this industry-dominating genre has produced—the elegiac revisionist Western to Marvel and DC’s cowboy serials.

Watch the full episode of Film Club below.